This doesn't stop saberfans from being especially annoying about it. Saberfans tend to think that because they have advanced stats to back up their argument, they KNOW who the deserving players are.
Naturally, Rob Neyer isn't going to let the All-Star debate go by without putting in his two cents.
I wasn't going to pick on Neyer, because the douchiest part of the column is actually a quote from Joe Sheehan. Then again, Rob makes a point to mention how much he agrees with Sheehan, so I won't cut him too much slack.
Neyer isn't content to just agree with Sheehan's douchieness. He needs to add some of his own:
But they're not qualified to evaluate the overall value of players they see a few times a year, because they've got little or no interest in doing the actual work that would require. How many of the players, before filling out their ballots, actually sat down and looked at Baseball-Reference.com or any other source listing something other than batting average and RBI's and wins and losses and ERA? A dozen, maybe?
|Is Miguel Cabrera worthy of being an All-Star? |
It's impossible to tell without hours of research.
Bud Selig should take the All-Star selection duty away from the players and the fans. He could then assign it to someone who would tirelessly scour reference sites in order to identify the players who are truly worthy of the All-Star honor. Obviously, there is only one man capable of handling this crucial responsibility: Rob Neyer.
If Neyer was assigned this sacred duty, he would construct the ultimate All-Star team rosters. Players would not be foolishly named All-Stars simply because they have a high RBI total. The result would surely be the greatest All-Star Game ever played; one that would be talked about for years to come.